Why is Ineffective & Unnecessary Spine Surgery So Common?

Despite clinical trials and studies showing that spine surgery isn’t beneficial for patients, it has become more common. In fact, when compared to non-surgical treatment, spinal fusion does not provide significantly better outcomes for patients. So why does unnecessary spine surgery continue to take place?

The decision of whether or not to undergo surgery is serious and should never be taken lightly. If you’re suffering from back or neck pain and have been told surgery is your only option, research your options. Make sure that spine surgery is truly the best option for your specific situation.

Factors Contributing to the Popularity of Unnecessary Spine Surgery

Studies show that spine surgery is rarely ever as effective as patients are led to believe it will be. A study of the Ohio Bureau of Worker’s Compensation database showed that 1,450 patients suffered from disc degeneration, disc herniation, and/or nerve disease. Of these 1,450 patients, almost 50% underwent spinal fusion surgery while the rest did not. Two years later, only 26% of patients who underwent surgery recovered enough to go back to work. However, 67% of patients who did not undergo surgery were able to return to work. 

Knowing studies simply don’t support the popularity of spine surgery, what could be contributing to its increasing popularity?

Financial Incentives

Many doctors perform surgery because it’s how they have been trained to deal with spine conditions. Unfortunately, there are also financial reasons for the popularity of unnecessary spine surgery. 

One of these incentives often comes in the form of physician-owned distributorships or PODs. A POD is a liaison between medical device manufacturers and hospitals. When a device is successfully marketed to a hospital, the distributorship receives a kickback from the manufacturers of the device. It’s common for physicians to own these types of distributorships, which creates a problem with PODs because the decision of which devices a hospital will purchase usually falls to physicians and surgeons. In this case, if the physician owns a distributorship, the physician will have a financial incentive to order devices that provide them with a kickback. This could then make the physician or surgeon more likely to recommend unnecessary spine surgery that uses this device.

Because of this, senators from multiple states have requested that the Inspector General investigate the legal validity of PODs.

There are also surgical fees for procedures like decompressions, and the fees range from $600 to $1,000. The more complex the surgery, the more surgeons earn from them.

In addition to this, while surgery is usually paid for after doctor approval, a high-quality program to rehabilitate a patient’s back can be very expensive and may not be covered by insurance.

Other Reasons

Other reasons why unnecessary spine surgery continues to be recommended despite what studies may show is that some surgeons genuinely feel that invasive procedures are beneficial to patients.

It’s also common for doctors and patients to choose certain approaches, like surgery, simply because they sound better or like they would be beneficial in some way, even if there’s no real evidence for it.

unnecessary spine surgery
By rawpixel.com – www.freepik.com

Questions to Ask Before Spine Surgery

While spine surgery is certainly beneficial in some cases, these cases aren’t very common, making spine surgery often unnecessary. The evidence simply does not show that surgery should be happening as often as it does. Because of this, you should make sure that surgery is the best choice for you before undergoing it. The following are some questions you can ask your physician if you’re recommended surgery.

  • What kind of operation is it? What will be done during the procedure?
  • Why is the operation necessary?
  • What are my risks and benefits of having the surgery?
  • Are there other, more conservative, treatment options available?
  • What are the risks and benefits of seeking other treatment?

The Discseel® Procedure

Remember, unnecessary spine surgery, and spine surgery in general, has many risks of intra- or postoperative complications, so the decision to undergo surgery should always be taken seriously, even if it’s only considered minimally invasive. 

You also have the option of considering a procedure that is non-surgical, minimally invasive, and known to provide lasting pain relief. The Discseel® Procedure treats back or neck pain caused by torn or damaged spinal discs, also known as annular tears. It treats annular tears by sealing torn spinal discs and encouraging your spinal discs to grow new tissue, completing the healing process.

If you’re ready to stop living with back or neck pain, apply for the Discseel® Procedure today and find out if you’re a candidate!

Featured image by peoplecreations – www.freepik.com

Scroll to Top